May 20, 2024


Free For All Food

Extensive Island Eatery Gets Higher Marks For Its Tasty Sauce, Common Italian Staples

The winner of the Bethpage Best of Extensive Island Award for best Italian restaurant, Gallery 4 has also gained the hearts of diners for their residence-produced sauce, primo chicken parm, and fair selling price point.

“Lived in Lynbrook for 3 decades and often drove by this location but hardly ever went in, these types of a disgrace simply because this was the finest sauce I have at any time experienced right here on Prolonged Island,” wrote Yelp! reviewer David D. of Gallery 4. “The decor is from the ’90s but so are the rates and the foodstuff is excellent. 

“Our new most loved Italian spot, pizza is great since their sauce is sweet and not bitter like most locations. Rooster park and shrimp parm for $14 you try to eat for two days. Adore it!”

Launched in 1979, The Gallery 4 Pizzeria & Italian Cafe has been serving up pizzas and Italian classics to Long Islanders for many years. 

The most expensive product on their menu, a Sicilian pie, is just more than $20, with other pizzas costing $17.50 and a simple cheese pizza coming in at $13.95. Only a handful of menu objects price about $17. 

Amid items on the in depth menu at Gallery 4 are: 

  • A quantity of “antipasti” merchandise, like fried zucchini, stuffed mushrooms, fried ravioli, cold antipasto, and baked clams
  • A sizeable pasta variety, including baked manicotti, stuffed shells, and selfmade lasagna
  • Very hot soups for less than $5, together with chicken noodle, minestrone alla Milanese and stracciatella alla romano
  • Stuffed eggplant, eggplant, rooster, veal, veal cutlet, and rooster cutlet parmigiana
  • Chicken Gallery, created with hen breast in white sauce topped with ham, broccoli and mozzarella
  • Hen marsala
  • Veal scallopine with peppers, veal scallopine marsala, and veal scallopine marsala with mushrooms
  • Hen cacciatore 
  • Rooster Francese
  • Zuppa di clams ala posillipo
  • Mussels fra diavolo
  • Stuffed filet of sole

The cafe also has a variety of hero sandwiches and a range of standard pizza pies. 

“Nothing fancy but a fantastic straightforward meal at a good value with the nicest folks,” wrote Ed M. on Yelp! “Came below due to the fact we required just that, an unpretentious spot that has excellent foods. Happy we came, look ahead to heading back again.”

to sign up for Daily Voice’s free day-to-day e-mail and information alerts.